Quacks lie. In some ways, that’s what separates us from them. Real doctors are stuck with the messy truth: with bad news, with uncertain outcomes. It’s this reliance on the truth which gives us much of our credibility.
Laws forcing doctors to lie to patients take me back to reading Kundera in the 80s; the hovering fear that everyday actions might bring the authorities to your door. These feelings affect every portion of your life, whether you are a patient or a doctor. Lying in service of the state is pervasively oppressive. Laws requiring doctors to lie have become a popular tactic in the abortion wars.